The selection of vacation rentals available here are perfect if you’re in the area and want to stay with more people in one place or you’re looking for your own space with a private deck or lake access. Renting a vacation house gives you more privacy and flexibility you need to make your Finger Lakes vacation exactly as you imagine it.

This is your opportunity to really get on the lake! Many houses are equipped with everything from Jacuzzi tubs, pools, kayaks, canoes or paddle boats. Check out the selection of vacation rentals and book your home away from home. We have you covered from small cottages to full-size lakefront homes.

Rentals for Any Occasion

Amish Guesthouse at Weaver View Farms

386 State Route 14
Penn Yan NY 14527
(315) 781-2571

Show on map

Back-Achres Cottage Rentals

2830 Jared Road
Himrod NY 14842
(607) 243-7926

Show on map

Basin Park Marina and Vacation Rentals

525 Mill Street
Branchport NY 14418
(315) 595-8808

Show on map

Basswood Beach House


Penn Yan NY 14527
(315) 536-4821

Show on map

Finger Lakes Premier Properties

103 Horizon Park Drive
Penn Yan NY 14527
(866) 309-7462

Show on map

Fulkerson Farmhouse

5552 State Route 14
Dundee NY 14527
(607) 227-4037

Show on map

Great-Getaway at Seneca Lake

4444 Hemlock Road
Dundee NY 14837
(607) 733-2371

Show on map

Grouse Haven Cabin

4346 Scott Road
Keuka Park NY 14478
(315) 651-9388

Show on map

Lakecrest Manor

4453-4475 East Bluff Drive
Penn Yan NY 14527
(585) 336-9657

Show on map

Linger Hospitality

270 Pine Road
Dundee NY 14837
(607) 218-7419

Show on map

Morgan Marine Cottage Rentals


Penn Yan NY 14527
(315) 536-8166

Show on map

North End Marina & Cottage Rentals

454 West Lake Road
Branchport NY 14418
(315) 595-2853

Show on map

Outlet Trail Cabin Rental

2046 Ridge Road
Penn Yan NY 14527
(315) 530-3110

Show on map

Savannah House Cottages


Himrod NY 14842
(540) 454-1933

Show on map

Saw Mill on Seneca

52 Sawmill Road
Dundee NY 14837
(610) 751-0939

Show on map

Sheridan House

13 Main Street
Penn Yan NY 14527
(202) 415-9190

Show on map

Stonehouse 1870

Coates Road
Keuka Park NY 14478
(908) 256-4440

Show on map

Tall Pines Above Seneca

5508 State Route 14
Dundee NY 14837
(607) 243-5181

Show on map

Wright's Cottages on Waneta Lake

9472 Lakeshore Drive
Hammondsport NY 14840
(607) 292-6786

Show on map